The cornerstone of your sales process will be SEO discovery calls. This is a 30-minute phone or video call with a potential client, allowing you to get to know each other. Think of it as a two-way interview to establish collaborative compatibility.
During a discovery call, you can determine if the prospect is the right fit for your business. And the prospect, in turn, gets to decide whether you are the best SEO provider for their business.
In this blog, I will share how having an organized agenda helps you master an SEO discovery call.
Creating an Agenda for SEO Discovery Calls
Let’s dive right into the six easy steps to creating an agenda for your SEO discovery calls.
1. Introduction (3 mins)
The introduction is where you get the chance to make a great first impression. Overall, this section of the call is stress-free and provides an overview of what will be covered. It establishes who is on the call and what role they play in the organization. Here’s an example of how to provide an overview during the introduction of an SEO discovery call. “During this call, I’d like to get to know more about your business. I’d also like to share more insight into how we approach SEO. I’ll also leave plenty of time to answer your questions. Does that sound good to you, (insert prospect’s name)?”
Slide right into getting to know the prospect's business goals after the introduction.
2. Getting to Know the Prospect’s Business (5-10 mins)
Asking the right questions is the key to successfully getting to know your prospect's business. It’s common for agencies to pepper prospective clients with dozens of questions. But Pathfinder SEO recommends asking two key questions, instead. Specific questions that will lead to an organic conversation about their current pain points and their target destination.
How have you approached SEO in the past? Listen carefully to the answer. This will show you how much the prospect values SEO, how much experience they have, and how familiar they are with SEO terms. You might gain an understanding of their expectations, as well as learn who’ll be working with you. Most importantly, you’ll learn what the prospect’s pain point is, and by default, understand the number one challenge they are trying to solve.
What would your business look like if Google suddenly sent you twice your current traffic? The answer to this question will help you understand what the prospect’s end destination is. Seek to find relatability during this step. Acknowledge the prospect’s pain, empathize, and show them that you have the solution to get them where they want to be.
With a handle on these two answers, you now understand the two key dynamics that will help you close the sale: the challenge the prospective customer faces (pain) and their goals (destination). Now, your job is to demonstrate how your solution will help the prospective customer move from pain to the destination.
3. How SEO is Evolving in the Age of AI (5 mins)
Take a few minutes during the discovery call to highlight how SEO continues to evolve—and why your approach is built to evolve with it.
You might say something like:
“SEO has never been static—it’s always been changing. What worked five years ago doesn’t work the same way today. And now, with AI transforming how people search and find information, SEO is more important—and more dynamic—than ever.”
Use this moment to connect SEO to a broader impact. SEO isn’t just about ranking on Google anymore. Let your prospect know that your work will help them show up across a growing number of platforms—like ChatGPT, Gemini, and Perplexity—where people ask questions and get AI-powered answers sourced from the web.
This is a great opportunity to differentiate your offering. While some providers are still focused only on keywords and rankings, you’re showing your prospect that you understand the bigger picture—and that your SEO strategy is built for long-term visibility.
You might wrap up with something like:
“We stay current with how search is changing—especially as AI tools influence what gets seen and how. That way, you’re not just investing in traffic from Google. You’re investing in a digital presence that gets discovered across all the platforms where your customers are looking for answers.”
4. Presenting the Solution (5 mins)
You’ve made the necessary introductions and identified the prospect’s goals. You have empathized with their pain points and emphasized the importance of needing a solid SEO strategy that evolves as SEO evolves. Now it's time to present your offering. This is the bridge that will move prospective customers from their current position to their desired destination.
It’s best to start by describing how your services help prospective customers achieve their goals. Remember, it’s not just about you or the SEO services packaging, or even your process. It's about the prospect's end goal and where you can insert value for them.
Here's an example of how to present solutions to prospects during a discovery call. “Here's how we are going to get you qualified traffic that increases your leads. We'll start by targeting more specific (longer) phrases that will help us with early wins. We'll focus our efforts on the most important pages on your website for generating leads and closing sales. As our campaign matures, we can compete for more competitive keywords. We'll move from these specific phrases to broader, higher volume phrases.”
Note that you aren't explaining the mechanics. Instead, you’re focusing on explaining how the service delivers value. This serves as the perfect segue into presenting the offering.
5. Outline the Next Steps (5 mins)
Now we want to present the specific offering you are selling. Most often this will be an SEO Assessment. Sometimes, you may elect to skip this initial process and dive straight into the SEO Set-Up. You can determine which starting point suits the situation from the established rapport with the prospect thus far.
Your goal here is to successfully present an onramp into your service offerings. Focus closer on delivering verbiage that highlights where you bring value here. It makes the decision an easy and often excited yes for the prospect because you made it a no-brainer.
For example, “If you want to get started, I'd recommend a short-term project to create your SEO strategy. We call this an SEO Assessment. The project costs $X and is completed in a relatively short period of a week or two. With this Assessment, you'll walk away with an understanding of where your website is today and a roadmap for growth. Then, of course, we can build a long-term project to take action on this strategy if you are comfortable.”
Also, include a few nuts and bolts in this part of the description. Note when the prospective customer will hear from you again and what they can expect. For example, “I'll be in touch on Wednesday of this/next week with a formal proposal for this project.”
And just like that, you’ve pitched your offering to your prospective client in a professional and succinct amount of time. All while covering the fundamentals and getting the client excited for the next steps toward their end goal of success.
6. Q/A (5 mins)
Save time at the end of the conversation to leave space for the client to ask any questions. Don’t hesitate to flatter them a bit here, too. Express your desire to work with them and genuinely share the passion you have for helping them achieve their goals. Ask if there are any concerns whatsoever to keep the transparency wide open. This helps establish trust in the working relationship from the beginning and allows the prospect to feel comfortable voicing their opinion. This will only serve the two of you better when true collaboration begins.
The most frequently asked question you'll here is, “When will I see results?”
In your answer, you want to make sure your prospect understands everything that is required to “get results”. This includes re-explaining to them the importance of having a strategy, and the longevity of SEO. This only highlights the necessity for continued maintenance — which you offer, right? Further, explain that this means moving them from the initial SEO Assessment into action items.
Remember you can't guarantee specific rankings or traffic increases. You can guarantee a focused SEO campaign that is crafted around leveraging your expertise to drive results as quickly as possible. Further guarantee you'll communicate what you discover and see in those results along the way to bring the prospect alongside you in this journey figuratively.
What's Next
You are on your way to mastering the art of selling SEO services! Create your discovery call agenda and then go get your first SEO sales call booked.
We're Here to Help
Pathfinder SEO gives you the courses, coaching, and community to start, grow, and scale your SEO offering.
With guided SEO, you can:
- Craft a future-proof SEO strategy for your client,
- Identify the quick SEO wins for your client’s website,
- Leverage our process documentation to deliver SEO projects with ease,
- Get answers to questions and feedback on projects,
- Be a part of a community of agency owners looking to share SEO strategies and tactics,
- Stay up to date with the latest in SEO and generative AI in search.
Join our community today and deliver SEO services with confidence.
Pathfinder makes SEO approachable, impactful and fun!
This course is part of the Pathfinder approach to SEO, a guided system. Membership includes:
Courses — Distilling decades of experience into actionable SEO courses and training. Take a step-by-step approach.
Coaching — You don’t have to go it alone. We’ll be here with group and 1:1 coaching.
Community — Stay updated on all things SEO with our engaged community.
All for $99/month. Cancel anytime.
